Customer Reviews

See what our customers have to say about our products!

Recent Praise

Wow, Wow, Wow!!!!

Leanne T.

Verified Purchase

★★★★★

I happened upon Janet's Cookie Jar on Facebook Marketplace while looking for a place where I could buy custom cookies. I messaged Janet, and we had a brief conversation over messenger and email. All I said was that I was looking for 2 dozen cookies with a barnyard theme for a baby shower. I wasn't quite sure what to expect. What I got was 24 of THE MOST ADORABLE AND DELICIOUS cookies I've ever seen! Janet went far above and beyond! Check out the cute little chick on the corner of the baby bottle. Every baby bottle had a tiny, cute, different animal! Now I am looking for excuses to serve custom cookies!!! I will definitely order from Janet again .... everything about the experience went super smoothly and the product was outstanding.

4/14/2026

Cutest Birthday Cookies 🍪

Claire B.

★★★★★

My friend sent some cookies from Janet’s Cookie Jar for my sons’s first birthday. Not only were they adorable, but delicious too! Highly recommend & can’t wait to order more!! 😋

3/29/2026

She’s the best!!!!

Heather B.

Verified Purchase

★★★★★

Janet did an amazing job on the cookies for my baby shower! I gave her a theme and a few inspo pics, and she absolutely nailed it. Not only were they beautiful, but they tasted incredible too! I’ve also ordered her Christmas and Easter cookies, and she never disappoints. 5 stars all the way—highly recommend!

3/28/2026

Averee Jimenez Review

We received our cookies from Janet and are very pleased. The ordering process was smooth, she was very friendly, we received them on time and the cookies are out of this world good! The detail on the cookies almost makes you not want to eat them! The packaging was beautiful too. We also ordered caramels, they are so soft and not too sweet and they are wrapped with care! Thank you very much, we will be ordering again soon!

Taken from Facebook

Krystina Werner Review

Just a shout out for an amazing baker with some creative skills when it comes to decorating. I stumbled upon these delicious fun cookies over the holidays and had to have Janet create several orders for me and some last minute and she made it happen. 5 stars with a smile is what you will get when you purchase cookies from Janet’s Cookie Jar. Thank you and will be placing an order soon for birthdays.

Customer Feedback

Averee Jimenez Review

Krystina Werner Review

Customer Review Form